Sign in Pro
Best Insoles for Running Reviews – 2024
Many of these designs are built specifically for runners and provide extra cushioning and support where runners need it most. We love them because they help runners suffering from plantar fasciitis, or need extra arch support. Plus, they are also ideal for runners carrying a little extra weight due to the increased impact absorption.
In this guide, we have selected some of the best insoles for running to fix your feet pain without investing in a new pair of pricey trainers!
Standout Picks
Criteria Used for Evaluation
Materials
High-quality materials can offer high-end cushioning without a lot of extra weight or bulk.
The material insoles are made of can give some indication as to their comfort and cushion. Many inserts consist of gel or foam, while others remain minimal and use cotton or textile materials. Others have hybrids of these materials. All of these types were chosen because they are the most popular among insoles and provide enough versatility to cover different needs based on the individual’s preference.
Gel
Gel, rather than foam in most cases, is a lot lighter and catered towards those who have pain when walking/running for extended durations. Obviously, gel insoles can provide top of the line pain relief and are more of a therapeutic type sole as they are marketed as “massaging Gel insoles.” On the other hand, gel insoles can play a more important part in impact-related exercises as the material is more suited for managing stress than foam is.
For example, the Full-Length Neutral Arch Insole by Sof Sole although mainly composed of foam, has a gel heel for reducing the shock associated with cross-fit and running.
Pros
✓ Budget-friendly
✓ Durable
✓ Easy to clean
✓ Retains shape
✓ Great for impact
Cons
✓ Heavy
✓ Require socks to prevent slippage during heat and perspiration
✓ Not a breathable material
Foam
Foam is more for long, drawn-out running as the materials are quite comfortable and can withstand a lot of stress; much like the gel insoles can. Also, foam insoles are superior when it comes to moisture-wicking features as well as breathability. Not all foam is created equal either.
Some foam is a blend of materials and will vary in stiffness, to either add an extra cushion or be slightly more firm for high impact use. Most Foam insoles will conform to your foot over time, so no area will be without some sort of support or cushioning.
Pros
✓ Comfortable and soft
✓ Conform to your unique foot shape
✓ Reduce fatigue and shock absorption
✓ Great for fitness or non-fitness related uses
✓ Usually, have a solid base to help support arches
Cons
✓ Not as durable as gel insoles, and may wear out more quickly
✓ Depending on the blend of material used, they can get warm
In the end, it all comes down to what you’re looking for in general. Foam and gel insoles can cover a majority of users' needs and preferences, but if you’re looking for additional options, you can always consider air insoles (not included here), but do note they can run more expensive than foam or gel insoles.
Effectiveness
At the end of the day, you simply need something that can effectively combat foot pain.
Pain relief and comfort, for the most part, go together because if you’re comfortable, odds are you aren’t experiencing any pain. Both pain relief and comfort are two huge components that an insole has to deliver because it essentially dictates whether or not you’re going to invest in the sole in the first place.
Stock insoles, for the most part, aren’t high enough quality to fix pain associated with exercising, which is why both of these features were taken into account when making our list.
Pain Relief
Every insole on our list aids in pain relief although some may be better at it than others. Pain relief also subsections down into shock absorption as this is also another very important feature in reducing the stress applied on your foot when running.
It’s important to note that if you’re experiencing prolonged pain, you may want to see a podiatrist to make sure there are no serious issues. Most pain from running can come from pronation that is not supported or stabilized, heel spurs, bunions, hammertoe, high or flat arches that require extra cushion or structural support, or even bow-leggedness. If you do experience pain, try to select an insole that provides structural support as well as a cushion for running.
If insoles don’t cut it, you can always switch to orthotics, some of which are listed here as well. Orthotics are slightly different than insoles as they will have further firm support in the arch to help correct pronation and stabilize the foot.
Comfort
If they aren't comfortable, you are less likely to wear them!
Comfort is another big one because sometimes you just get that shoe that’s just awful to wear whether it be casually, or for exercising because of a number of contributing factors. Perhaps the fit isn’t quite right, or it fits great but lacks adequate cushioning.
Both gel and foam insoles are great for comfort, creating great synergy with the footwear you already own. The BLUE Premium Insoles by SuperFeet, for example, are a foam insert and one of the most comfortable insoles on the market. On the other hand, Heel pad insole above has a thick foam heel pad that doubles as a pain relief feature for high impact activities.
Support
Do your favorite running shoes simply just have worn arch support that no longer gives you structural stability you need? If so, something like an orthotic with firmer arch support could be a good option as an insert for you.
Cushioning
Does your favorite sneaker simply have cushioning that’s become matted down from use, or lost its ability to provide any sort of impact absorption? You may find your feet simply being a bit sorer after your runs if this is the case.
Here, an insole with foam, gel, or other cushioning throughout the entirety of the insert could benefit you best. Options on our list include thick foam to a minimalist cushion.
Use
We made sure to select designs that are compatible with all designs of trainers and that are easy to adjust.
Different types of activities require different footwear, and the same often goes for inserts. Whether you're running, walking, cross-training or just sitting at your desk at the office will greatly influence what you need from a pair of insoles.
If you want to invest in a quality pair of inserts, but want them to be versatile enough to be used with more than a single pair of shoes, we recommend going with something that covers several categories.
This will include arch support, cushioning to aid the shock absorption of your running shoes, moisture wicking to prevent odors and hygiene issues, as well as a fit that works well with each pair of shoes you put them in.
It is important to note, however, that not all products will work with each of your shoes, so overall, you may need to invest in more than just one insert.
Value
We made sure to select designs that are not only comfortable and supportive, but affordable as well.
if you haven’t tried a pair of insoles or orthotics previously, before tossing your favorite pair of running shoes, it’s a good idea to invest in a budget-friendly insole just to see if you can get more life from those sneakers without purchasing an entirely new pair.
Many times, cushion in a running shoe can be the first thing to go, and insoles will help prolong the life of that cushioning until other aspects of the sneaker require a full replacement pair. And, if you like the insoles you do purchase, you can wear them in other shoes you have in your collection for comfort during any event, work, or casual stroll about town!
Otherwise, to get the best bang for your buck, look for insoles that are constructed with durable materials and that may serve for more than just a single purpose. It is also important to keep in mind that inserts need to be replaced every three to six months, to ensure you're getting the right amount of shock absorption, that the support hadn't flattened out, and that they haven't become a breeding ground for fungus and bacteria.
Regular cleaning and proper drying can help prolong this period (and some models are made to last longer), but overall, don't forget to check your inserts for signs of deterioration every once in a while. This will keep your feet healthy and pain-free in the long run.
10 Best Insoles for Running
1. SOLE Softec Ultra-U
SOLE Softec Ultra-U hits the top of our list for a number of reasons. It’s AMPA approved and backed by podiatrists, so you can rest assured you are getting a quality product many doctors endorse. It’s also the thickest insert cushion one can add to your shoes to help with loose or ill fit, or provide additional shock absorption and cushioning. And with a moldable construction, this insert will mold to your foot without losing critical arch support.
Sole Softec is designed with 20% recycled material and is moldable to your unique foot over time. A polyester weave on the top layer of the insert promotes a wicking action to leave your feet dry and is also made with 35% recycled materials. You can feel good about placing these in your running shoes for a quick trail run!
Designed to help pronation imbalances, the arch support found in the Ultra-U provides just enough support without being excessively rigid. A heel cup helps to stabilize the heel and give proper heel-to-toe exchange during foot strikes. EVA and PU blend keep this insole cushioned, light, and supportive, and with a 3.2mm thickness, you can log in those long runs without pain.
On the more expensive side of our list, but by no means over the top, these are a quality buy for runners who find themselves logging over 20 miles a week, or go long on a regular basis. The additional arch support and cushion can help keep your feet and run going instead of fading due to tired arches and pain. These best running insoles are a great investment for advanced runners!
2. SuperFeet Blue Premium
The Blue Premium by SuperFeet takes on rather a more lightweight approach than the brand's heritage model. In essence, the Blue Premium's are a great shock-absorbing running insole suitable for longer distances and great in smaller to more medium-cut running shoes.
SuperFeet has a thing for being eco-friendly, so all of their insoles are composed of vegan and organic compounds which means they're free of latex and other harsh materials, a great niche feature that helps save the earth!
The cushioning on these insoles are top of the line as they boast a fantastic shock-absorbing heel cup in addition to multiple layers of foam, which is what makes them so good for running long distances! Ideally, these running insoles should be utilized if you are looking for intermediate levels of support without taking up too much space in the shoe.
The higher price tag on this pair of insoles is to be expected as the materials used are eco-friendly and cost more than cheaper chemicals. With the price tag put to the side though, these are a great pair of insoles for running shoes that are unique and can be used in any running environment especially for those long-distance jogs.
3. Sof Sole Neutral Arch
The gel and foam hybrid construction featured in this pair of running insoles is great for high impact training such as running and cross-fit where foot protection is essential. The neutral arch of this insole makes it perfect for almost any shoe, and a great option for everyday athletes who need a good sole to go with their flats.
As mentioned above, the heel is protected with gel which is why this insole is so great for higher impact activities. With the addition of the gel heel pad, the forefoot is much more comfortable for long term usage.
Being able to wick moisture efficiently is extremely important for athletic shoes. Hydrologix Technology is one of the best options out there in this department and is sure to keep your feet free of sweat when out exercising. These full-length neutral arch inserts are a fantastic budget option for all types of athletic training specifically higher impact activities.
Also offering great protection and comfort when out exercising, theirs no question why these running insoles are such a popular choice among athletes. These are without a doubt one of the best insoles for running on concrete.
4. Spenco Polysorb
The Polysorb Cross Trainer by Spenco is an insole that’s designed primarily for more cushioned support, and a neutral arch. Constructed from nylon, it has a super plush heel to help absorb impact, and a toe crash pad to cushion the forefoot. This type of insole is well suited to high impact sports such as running but can also be used in cross-training activities, such as CrossFit, HIIT sessions, or garage type workout sessions.
Spenco uses a polysorb polyurethane foam in its insole, which keeps it relatively lightweight. The thick cushion is found in the heel which helps to absorb high impact, and absorb shock from activities such as jumping or intense interval sessions running. An additional heel plug can be seen underneath the insert, which gives a little additional cushion. Forefoot crash pad design alleviates forefoot pressure.
Nylon helps keep these cushioned insoles for running shoes slightly stretchy and flexible, helping to prevent blistering. The fabric has been treated for antimicrobial resistance to help control odor. EVA construction in the forefoot helps provide lightweight cushioning and energy return so that you can keep a spring in your step over longer sessions of training.
One of the least expensive on our list, the Spenco Polysorb Cross Trainer is ideal for those who need added cushioning and have a neutral arch. It’s ideal for cross training activities where high impact movements are performed with its superior cushion and heel plug. Be sure to check sizing, and adjust the insole should you need to so it fits perfectly in your shoes.
5. Powerstep Pinnacle
The Powerstep Pinnacle is an insert made for moderate pronator support but mainly served to relieve pain from plantar fasciitis, or those looking for additional cushioning or some arch support insoles for running. Its arch support is firm yet flexible and cradles the heel, all helping to provide stability during running, and greater control of motion. Best of all, it’s made with an anti-microbial fabric on top, sure to help those who needed added protection from excessive perspiration.
The foam base of the Pinnacle is made from EVA foam, durable for extended wear, and is combined with Variable Cushioning Technology. This provides targeted cushioning from a dual-layer that acts similar to memory foam. It cushions areas of your unique foot where the impact may be heavier during foot strikes on the ground.
The top layer of these insoles for running shoes is designed from an anti-microbial fabric, helping to keep bacteria from building up over time. This feature is especially helpful for those whose feet may perspire more so than normal, or for distance runners who spend long hours training. It helps to reduce heat and friction to keep your feet cooler and drier.
Similarly priced as our number one pick, the Powerstep Pinnacle is a solid purchase for those looking for extra cushion during their runs. Ideal for keeping your feet dry and preventing the buildup of bacteria from hot sessions, it will have you going longer in comfort and keep your sneakers smelling good.
6. Physix Gear Sport
This pair of full-length orthotic inserts were made for athletes who need superior shock absorption, while still requiring a good amount of anatomical support in order to treat and prevent conditions such as plantar fasciitis and heel spurs. The Physix Gear Sport insole is made in five sizes that can be adjusted to fit your favorite pair of running shoes.
The anatomical design of the Physix Gear Sport helps with pronation issues, guiding the foot to hit the ground, as well as to push off with correct alignment, which prevents users from putting too much, or unnecessary pressure on the inside of the foot. This helps relieve metatarsal and bunion pain, and can even help those with knee issues.
The materials used in this product are of high quality - it’s made with medical-grade EVA and PU which are cushioning and durable, while the antimicrobial top layer prevents bacterial and fungal overgrowth that may lead to unpleasant odors or issues such as athlete’s foot. An additional benefit of this item is the fact that the heel is designed with non-slip materials that ensure proper placement, regardless of whether you’re running in these insoles for runners, or wearing them inside your casual footwear.
The price is slightly higher than average, but anyone looking for the best insoles for runners knee that works also great for flat feet will find these to be a good investment.
7. EasyFeet
No matter that the reasoning for your foot pain, this design from EasyFeet has you covered. This design is specifically designed for runners that suffer from overpronation, plantar fasciitis, high or flat arches, or simply for runners that need an extra layer of shock absorption. Plus, they come in at a super affordable price point that won’t break the bank.
One of the very first things that we noticed about this design is that it is composed of premium materials. It boasts a main layer of TPU cushioning that cradles your foot in place to help with overpronation that leads to knee and lower back pain. On top of the TPU layer is a soft layer of PU foam that provides additional support and comfort when running on hard surfaces.
The very top layer is where this design really shines. It is composed of a velvety material that helps to disperse heat and sweat to keep your feet feeling cool, dry, and comfortable. Some insoles have a reputation of being a little hot and bulky, but this design from EasyFeet feels like it was built specifically for your style of trainers.
If you are in the market for something that is lightweight and comfortable to provide relief from arch pain or pain from overpronation, this design from EasyFeet is worth checking out. We love the contoured shape that cradles your foot in place without the use of heavy and hot materials that will keep your feet cool and dry, even on those long runs.
8. Dr. Scholl’s Sport
Dr. Scholl’s is a brand that has been in the market for making comfortable shoe insoles since 1906, so it is no wonder they are making an appearance on this list. What we love most about the Sport Insole is that it is designed specifically for the needs of all runners. It is composed of lightweight and breathable materials that cradle your foot in place and an extra spring in your step. Plus, they come in at an incredibly affordable price point.
What makes this design ideal for runners is that it boasts specific features that runners need. The flexible arch shell cradles your arches in place for excellent stability and provides additional support for side to side motions that can cause feet to become strained and tired.
We also love that this design is composed of super comfortable gel technology. The gel cushioning has small grooves that massage your feet in all stages of your gait to provide excellent cushioning and energy feedback on those long runs. Plus, it is incredibly lightweight and isn’t as stiff as some of the other designs that we have seen.
If you are in the market for something that is super affordable and hails from one of the most trusted brands in the industry, this option from Dr. Scholl’s is a great choice. This brand is widely available, you are likely to find it at any local drugstore at a super affordable price point.
9. Powerstep Original
Powerstep is known for its high-quality, American made products that are podiatrist recommend, and are tried and true in the world of running shoes and insoles. The Powerstep Original Insoles feature a full-length construction in addition to a bunch of other features that aid in ease of use as well as comfort when using.
Being lightweight is obviously a huge key factor when looking for an insole, and the Powerstep Originals fit the description perfectly. Their ultra-thin design is composed of Polypropylene materials and also features dual-layer cushioning to be both comfortable and suitable for essentially all styles of shoes.
The full-length Powerstep running shoe insoles boast a firm yet also flexible shell as well as arch support and a heel cradle. Added arch and heel support are great to have when looking for running inserts because they provide a level of versatility and safety that you can’t get with regular insoles.
There's no question why Powerstep has become one of the leading brands in the insole market as their products are extremely well made, and are of excellent quality in general. Seeing as the price is nothing too high, these insoles make a perfect budget and high-quality option.
10. Plemo Gel Sports
Simplicity is the name of the game when it comes to this design from Plemo. We love that it boasts an airy and flexible frame that helps to cradle your foot in place to prevent foot pain on those long runs. It has ventilation holes to keep your feet cool and dry and targeted reinforcement zones in the heel and toe box provided added durability.
Measuring in at 3.5 mm, this design is super cushioning, but some find that it is a little snug inside of most trainers. It is composed of lightweight foam that helps to cushion and protect your feet on those long training days. We also love that it boasts ventilation holes to keep your feet cool and dry.
This design really shines in the construction of the heel and toe box. Added gel reinforcement zones provide you with extra support in high-impact zones, which help to keep your feet protected and supportive without a lot of extra bulk. The best of this design? It is one of the most affordable options currently out there on the market.
If you spent all of your extra cash on a killer pair of trainers and don’t have much left for insoles, this design from Plemo is a great choice. Not only does it come in at a super affordable price point, but it is also packed with lightweight and breathable features to help keep your feet supported and pain-free.
Sources
- , Frequently Asked Question, Consumer Website
- , The orthotics debate: How running shoe inserts are dividing the experts, Sports Website
- , Do You Need Insoles For Your Running Shoes?, Sports Blog